专题 | SBF审判进行时,昔日「加密之王」终局如何?
专题 | SBF审判进行时,昔日「加密之王」终局如何?
被捕 9 个月零 20 天后,FTX 创始人 SBF 在于当地时间 10 月 3 日出庭受审,庭审为期6周,各种内部文件和录音内容等证据曝光,各方证人证词也随之登场。SBF及FTX案件将迎来何种结局?
直击SBF庭审现场
最新进展
2023-08-30 02:23:05
Federal prosecutors rebut SBF's allegations regarding the evidence documents.
Odaily News: A court document on Tuesday revealed that US federal prosecutors are questioning SBF's allegations regarding evidence documents. Last Friday, SBF requested a ban from the Southern District of New York court, preventing a large number of documents from being used as evidence during the October trial. The reason behind this request is that the prosecutors provided SBF's defense team with "millions of pages" of documents in the two months leading up to the trial, which SBF argues may not have given them sufficient time to review. The prosecutors countered that this accusation is "misleading," as SBF had access to these documents through their Google account several months ago, thus making it unreasonable to claim that the government's materials provided were biased against them. In previous news, a document submitted to the Southern District of New York court on August 25 stated that SBF's legal team argued that, according to the prosecutors' proposed plan, SBF would have limited time to review the evidence materials before the trial. On August 24, the US Department of Justice provided approximately 4 million pages of evidence materials, along with "millions of pages of documents and a large amount of data" for SBF to review prior to the criminal trial. The lawyers stated that unless SBF is temporarily released, no other measures can appropriately address these issues or guarantee SBF's right to participate in their own defense.
2023-09-09 02:26:51
SBF lawyer: SBF still cannot access the Internet normally, so he applied for temporary release again
Odaily News SBFs defense attorney said in a memo late Friday that prosecutors exaggerated SBFs ability to access defense materials. It is said that when SBF was taken to a cell in the Southern District of New York Court, he still could not access the Internet normally, and it was far from the level that the Department of Justice said he could access the Internet. SBFs defense team has sought to have him temporarily released or given more computer access to mount a defense, saying his Sixth Amendment rights were violated; while prosecutors insist they revoked bail last month on public safety grounds. Finally, SBF can obtain defense materials. It is reported that earlier this week, the U.S. Department of Justice submitted a letter saying that SBF now has access to multiple hard drives provided by the defense that store defense materials, as well as a laptop with an air-gapped system every day, and a Internet-connected laptop with new battery provided by defense counsel. In response, defense attorneys wrote that the scheme did not work in practice, and Judge Lewis Kaplan ordered SBFs team to detail what they believed to be inaccuracies. Fridays letter detailing the issues said SBF was taken to court on Wednesday and given access to a computer with internet access, but due to poor internet speeds he could only load one document. The letter said: Nearly a full month has passed since Mr Bankman-Fried (SBF) was remanded in custody and we have lost time to effectively prepare for trial. We would therefore like to reiterate our request that the court order an interim release Mr. Bankman-Fried. (CoinDesk) Previous news, in a document submitted to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit on September 6, court clerk Catherine OHagan Wolfe stated that a circuit judge dismissed the SBF legal teams request Motion to immediately release SBF from Brooklyn Metropolitan Detention Center. SBFs lawyer once argued that SBF could only use the computer twice a week, and there were problems with the battery and signal, which had a significant impact on the defense.
2023-09-12 03:20:53
FTX owns 38 properties in the Bahamas with a book value of $222 million
Odaily News According to court documents, the assets of the bankrupt crypto exchange FTX included digital assets, cash, brokerage investments, venture capital portfolios, tokens and real estate, totaling $7 billion. FTX owns 38 properties in the Bahamas with a book value of $222 million. The documents show that 50 insiders including SBF and Caroline Ellison received $2.2 billion worth of cash, cryptocurrency, equity and real estate. (Cointelegraph) Previously, FTX creditor @sunil_trades released an FTX shareholder report updated on September 11 on the X platform. The report pointed out that based on the market price on August 31, FTX (including FTX.com, FTX.US, Alameda) held a total of approximately US$3.4 billion worth of crypto assets. Sorted according to the value of the positions, the order is: 1. SOL, the position value is about 1.162 billion U.S. dollars; 2. BTC, the position value is about 560 million U.S. dollars; 3. ETH, the position value is about 192 million U.S. dollars; 4. APT, the position value is about 1.37 5. USDT, with a holding value of approximately $120 million; 6. XRP, with a holding value of approximately $119 million; 7. BIT, with a holding value of approximately $49 million; 8. STG, with a holding value of approximately $46 million; 9. WBTC , with a position worth approximately US$41 million; 10. WETH, with a position worth approximately US$37 million. The above-mentioned 10 major currencies account for 72% of the total FTX crypto asset holdings, and the remaining 28% of the holdings are composed of more than 400 other tokens.
2023-09-19 15:02:21
SBF parents oppose FTX lawsuit against them
Odaily News FTX’s lawsuit against Joe Bankman and Barbara Fried, the parents of founder SBF, has been countered by legal representatives of SBF’s parents. Lawyers stated that this action by FTX was an attempt to intimidate Joe and Barbara in the days before SBFs upcoming trial and undermine the jury process. FTX alleges that SBF’s parents “used their access and influence within FTX’s businesses to directly and indirectly earn millions of dollars for themselves.” Court documents also claim that Joe lobbied SBF to increase his annual salary from $200,000 to $1 million, and asked SBFs mother to facilitate the process. Additionally, the filing states that the couple used FTX funds to receive a $16.4 million property in the Bahamas, as well as donations to Stanford University, participation in a Super Bowl commercial and a Persian rug worth more than $2,500. (The Block) Earlier news, FTX has sued Joseph Bankman and Barbara Fried, the parents of founder and former CEO Sam Bankman-Fried, requesting the recovery of millions of dollars in fraudulent transfers and misappropriations. Court documents state: FTX Trading paid $18,914,327.82 for Blue Water, for which Bankman and Fried obtained title, including taxes, fees and costs, and various charges related to Blue Water, totaling more than $90,000. Bankmans knowledge of tax laws and His unique understanding of the FTX Group’s chaotic corporate structure enabled him to facilitate the transfer of cash gifts totaling $10 million consisting of Alameda Ltd. funds to himself and Fried.”
2023-09-22 03:42:18
CoinDesk disclosed the SBF October trial process, which is expected to take 6 weeks
Odaily News FTX founder SBF will go to trial in less than two weeks to defend his case against charges that he knowingly committed fraud and conspired to defraud crypto investors and customers of FTX and Alameda Research. The trial is expected to take six weeks and is scheduled to begin on October 3. CoinDesk issued a statement stating that the trial process of this case includes jury selection, reasonable doubt, unanimous verdict and sentencing. Regarding jury selection, legal experts said that although the trial is scheduled to begin next month, the first steps in jury selection may begin as early as next week, when the judge will set the final witness schedule, determine the length of the trial, and evaluate all pending cases. Motion for ruling. Jury questioning will officially begin on October 3. The judge will ask potential jurors a series of questions, and will then begin to ask jurors questions from both the prosecution and the defense. Attorneys believe a fierce battle between the defense and prosecution for each juror could take days, but the Justice Department believes it will only take a day. Regarding reasonable doubt, the trial begins with opening statements from the U.S. Department of Justice and the defense, followed by the presentation of evidence and questioning of witnesses by the U.S. Department of Justice. Pretrial filings from the U.S. Department of Justice indicate that in addition to written documents, prosecutors will provide audio recordings during the trial. The U.S. Department of Justice may turn to FBI agents as first witnesses, or it may call in people from FTXs inner circle. Given that this is a criminal trial, the Justice Department must prove guilt “beyond a reasonable doubt.” In civil cases, the “preponderance of the evidence” standard is lower. Once the prosecution adjourns, the defense will have a chance to present additional witnesses. It is unclear whether SBF will testify in its own defense. Regarding unanimous verdicts, federal criminal trials require unanimous verdicts to obtain a conviction. If the jury consists of 12 people, all 12 must find SBF guilty at the end of the trial, and the defense only has to convince one juror that there was insufficient evidence. If the jury comes back after several attempts to reach a verdict and expresses that they have irreconcilable differences on all charges, the judge may declare a mistrial. Otherwise, the jury may reach a conviction on all or some of the charges, or convict on all or some of the charges. Acquitted. Regarding sentencing, if SBF is convicted of one or more of the charges he faces, how long he will spend in prison will largely depend on the judge. Sentencing guidelines are viewed more as a starting point than strict rules. The U.S. Probation and Pretrial Services System will first create a report that includes preliminary calculations of recommended sentencing ranges, before the Department of Justice and defense teams can raise any objections arguing for a longer or shorter sentence. His team is also likely to appeal if SBF is convicted. This is not the SBFs last criminal trial. He will also face new charges filed by the Justice Department early next year following an initial indictment. (CoinDesk)
2023-09-26 12:15:45
SBF detention environment: overcrowding, no heating, poor lighting
Odaily News Former FTX CEO Sam Bankman-Fried is currently living in the Brooklyn Metropolitan Detention Center, one of the most notorious correctional facilities in the United States. SBF has been living in jail for six weeks after losing bail, and conditions are a far cry from the former billionaires old Caribbean home. The internet is slow and the living quarters are filthy, SBFs lawyers said. Cafeteria supplies were sparse. The SBF subsisted on bread and water, sometimes peanut butter. The Brooklyn Metropolitan Detention Center is a large two-building prison complex that houses more than 1,600 male and female inmates, many of whom are still Awaiting trial. Prisoners currently in custody also include former Honduran president Juan Orlando Hernandez, who has pleaded not guilty to drug trafficking charges, and Chinese businessman Guo Wengui, who has pleaded not guilty to fraud charges. An orientation manual for the facility shows that inmates wake up at 6 a.m. and must make beds, mop floors and pick up trash. From there, inmates like SBF may go to work around the prison, serving as prep cooks in the prison kitchen, providing janitorial services throughout the complex, or assisting in the prisons maintenance shop. At 11 a.m. they have lunch. Dinner was served at 4 p.m. The meal was supposed to include meats such as turkey, starch such as rice, and vegetables or fruit, but inmates were actually eating cold cuts, sandwich bread, moldy pound cake and other unidentifiable foods from the kitchen ”, SBF is a vegetarian, and if he doesn’t like the food served in the cafeteria, he can use his weekly $150 concession stand allowance to buy peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, worth $3.65 each. According to the rules of the complex, he can buy up to two of them per day. Prisoners can rest. However, the detention center has no areas for recreational activities. SBF will have to hang out with his fellow inmates in an indoor community room where they can play cards, chat and watch TV. Rooms in dormitories and prisons are kept in semi-darkness 24 hours a day, and prisoners can often be heard shouting loudly in their cells throughout the night. Many areas of the detention center lack heating, and most facilities have few air conditioning units. At the end of each day, SBFs may end up in communal dormitories with rows of bunk beds. However, it is also possible that he has been placed in protective custody and given his own separate room. (CoinDesk)
2023-10-02 01:46:30
US judge: SBF cannot blame FTX collapse on legal team in opening statement
Odaily News Court documents show that U.S. District Court Judge Lewis A. Kaplan said on Sunday that SBF cannot blame FTX’s collapse or operations on its lawyers in opening statements, although he can still try to mount a so-called “counsel advice” defense later. . Previously, the SBF defense team claimed that FTX lawyers were “involved” in some of the company’s decisions. But Judge Kaplan said the lack of specific details could confuse or bias jurors. While the judge prevented the SBF defense team from mentioning outside counsel in opening statements, SBF lawyers could try to raise the issue later if they notified the judge and the Justice Department in advance and the jury was not present. (CoinDesk) According to previous news in August, SBF plans to argue at the trial in October that his previous provision of funds to FTX and Alameda executives, setting Signal messages to automatically delete, and setting up a series of North American entities were all out of good faith. conduct because he followed the advice of attorneys, including the law firm Fenwick West. SBFs defense team issued a letter detailing its proposed counsel advice strategy, saying it would provide evidence that in-house counsel and law firm Fenwick West were involved in reviewing and approving decisions relating to these matters. The defendants reliance on counsels evidence is relevant to the question of intent and is not limited to circumstances where the defense can demonstrate that the defendant formally sought the advice of counsel, received legal advice and followed the advice given, the letter said.
2023-10-02 04:34:02
SBF disagrees with US prosecutors request to allow Ukrainian witnesses to testify via video conference
Odaily reported that the U.S. prosecutor made a request to the federal court to allow a Ukrainian witness to testify via video conference, but the SBF did not agree to the U.S. prosecutor’s request. Prosecutors said in the document that the customer witness FTX Customer-1 lived in Ukraine and when Russia and Ukraine broke out in armed conflict in 2022, he lost most of his life savings that he had entrusted to FTX. Due to legal and logistical reasons, The reason is that the witness cannot easily travel to the United States, and prosecutors hope to allow him to testify remotely in the SBF criminal trial. (CNBC) Earlier news, the U.S. Department of Justice confirmed in two documents filed on Saturday that federal prosecutors hope to subpoena former FTX customers, investors and employees in the trial against SBF. Cooperating witnesses can speak about their relationship with the defendant and their understanding of the purpose of certain statements and actions by the defendant. Additionally, client witnesses may testify for no more than 30 minutes at a time and will involve minimal exhibits. The U.S. Department of Justice identified former FTX chief technology officer Gary Wang, former FTX engineering director Nishad Singh, and former Alameda Research CEO Caroline Ellison as three cooperating witnesses. They all admitted to FTX-related charges and will testify in court.
2023-10-04 06:27:39
CZ once rejected SBF’s $40 million proposal to cooperate on a futures trading platform, but was later willing to pay $80 million for 20% of FTX shares.
Odaily News The Big Short author Michael Lewis revealed in his new book Going Infinite that FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried (SBF) proposed cooperation to Binance founder CZ in early 2019, hoping to sell it for $40 million. The cryptocurrency futures trading platform technology developed by the team was introduced to Binance. In this proposal, Alameda Research is responsible for providing technical support, while Binance is responsible for bringing customer and market trust. After detailed deliberation, CZ decided to reject SBF’s proposal and chose to independently develop a futures trading platform. To this end, SBF has turned to independent development, intending to build a futures trading platform that can not only satisfy the cryptocurrency community, but also cater to large professional trading companies such as Jane Street. FTX initially issued 350 million FTT tokens, some of which were provided to employees at 5 cents, and some to important cryptocurrency figures, including CZ, at 10 cents. Although CZ and most FTX employees chose to refuse, the strong purchase demand from external investors prompted SBF to increase the token price from 20 cents to 70 cents. On July 29, 2019, FTT was listed on FTX, opening at $1 and later rising to $1.5. A few weeks later, CZ contacted SBF with an offer to buy 20% of FTX for $80 million.
2023-10-07 03:43:37
Inside the SBF case: FTX customer balances are equal to hot wallet assets, but there is an additional $8 billion in liabilities
Odaily News FTX Lianchuang Gary Wang testified in the SBF trial that in November 2022, FTX’s customer balances were equal to the assets held in the hot wallet, with one important exception: a hidden 80 named “fiat@” Billions of dollars in liabilities. As clients begin withdrawing assets from FTX in November 2022, SBF asked Gary Wang to calculate how much Alameda Research would need to deposit on the exchange to cover outflows. Wang, who testified under direct examination by government prosecutors on the fourth day of last weeks SBF trial, said that excluding Alameda Researchs account, the sum of FTX customer balances matched the assets in FTX hot wallets. But, unbeknownst to him, there was a problem with his calculations. He testified that he was only given the full picture when the SBF asked him whether he had included our Korean friends in the calculations. Confused, Wang checked with another former FTX executive, Nishad Singh, who told Wang that the Korean friends were actually referring to the $8 billion fiat@ vulnerability at the heart of FTXs collapse. The fiat@ account balance in FTXs internal database has been reassigned to an account named seoyuncharles88@gmail.com which has been granted special privileges so that Alameda Research does not have to pay interest on the credit line. Wang also confirmed that SBF knew that FTX’s financials were more transparent to the public and investors, while Alameda’s financials were not. (The Block)
2023-10-11 01:28:07
The first day of testimony by the former Alameda CEO ended. SBF lawyers filed a series of motions, including questioning about Anthropic shares.
Odaily News In SBF’s trial, its defense team plans to question Caroline Ellison about her reliance on legal advisors during her tenure as CEO of Alameda Research and the valuation of FTX’s stake in Anthropic AI. The defense team made the request after Ellison completed his first day of testimony. They also noted that Judge Lewis Kaplan had previously requested advance notice to discuss the possibility of an attorney-advised argument. The defense wants to hear about Ellisons role in shaping policies for FTX and Alamedas lawyers, such as the issue of activating automated deletion tools on the messaging app Signal. In addition, the U.S. Department of Justice has filed an objection to the issue of FTX investment valuation, arguing that it has nothing to do with whether SBF misappropriated FTX customer funds. Anthropic AI recently announced a series of fundraising efforts, raising hopes of greater compensation for FTX creditors. The defense team also said Anthropics news reflected important context in FTXs prospective value analysis, and therefore they should be entitled to raise broader questions about FTXs investment portfolio. At the end of the trial, the judge discussed with the defense the question of whether these issues should be raised at trial. There are other unresolved issues, including whether the U.S. Justice Department should be allowed to call a Ukrainian witness to testify remotely. (CoinDesk)